Friendly and Welcoming Dentists Providing State-of-the-Art Care

Learn More About Us

Aesthetic Oral Arts Focused on Creating Positive Patient Experiences

At Aesthetic Oral Arts in New Hartford, NY, we strive to provide the best possible experience every time you visit our dentists. Our team of dental professionals combines four decades of experience, comprehensive services, and advanced dental technology to exceed your expectations at every opportunity.

Aesthetic Oral Arts team Aesthetic Oral Arts team

Patient Membership Program Join and Save

New and existing patients at our New Hartford, NY, dental office can enjoy discounted services with our in-office membership plan. Contact us today to learn more.

“I was very, very impressed.”

Dr. Pfister curates an outstanding experience through patient education and advanced treatment.

Our Mission 

“We strive to offer patients a memorable dental experience. Our entire team is dedicated to providing patients with respectful, educational, and professional treatment to help them maintain their oral health in a welcoming environment.” The Aesthetic Oral Arts Team

Improve the Health and Charm of Your Smile  Schedule a Free Consultation Today

The best way to maintain a healthy smile is with regular trips to the dentist. If it's been a while since you've seen the dentist and you are ready to improve your dental health, the team at Aesthetic Oral Arts is here to help you achieve your goals. Our New Hartford office has plenty of parking, a cozy waiting area, and a relaxing atmosphere designed for your comfort.

During your appointment, you will be treated with kindness and compassion by our dedicated staff. Our dentists believe in educating patients so that they can make informed decisions about their care. You can count on us to help you feel comfortable and confident during your visit.

Schedule a free initial consultation and find out why so many in the community of New Hartford, NY, trust their smiles to Aesthetic Oral Arts. Contact us online or call:

(315) 724-7121

Dr. Timothy Pfister with a patient
We strive to provide the personalized care you deserve.

“Kind, Understanding, Professional Staff” 5-Star Google Reviews


Kat Watts


Google logo

Kind, understanding, professional staff who relieved my anxiety and examined me thoroughly, THEN came up with a comprehensive and reasonably priced plan to redeem my mouth. I have been through some dental brutality in the past and I feel confident I will be treated with care and respect in the restoration of my long neglected dental health.

View on Google

Cheryl Pula


Google logo

I've been going to Aesthetic Oral Arts for years, and have never been disappointed. Just recently, I broke a tooth and had to have a crown. With the COVID virus, I wasn't sure I'd be able to get in, but I did and they took care of it. I have always had great service from them. The staff is not only professional but very pleasant and accommodating, and Dr. Pfister is fantastic and very personable. I recommend him and them highly.

View on Google

Meet Dr. Pfister Exceptional Service for Over 35 Years

For over 35 years, Dr. Timothy Pfister has used the safest and most innovative dentistry treatments to provide the highest level of care. He is a proud member of the New Hartford community who is passionate about helping his neighbors achieve a better quality of life through sophisticated and comprehensive dental care.

Dr. Pfister takes a holistic approach to dentistry by designing treatments that contribute to every aspect of your health. For example, a crown from Dr. Pfister does not simply repair a tooth—it contributes to a properly balanced bite, which minimizes strain on your jaw joints and helps you to chew comfortably.

Dr. Pfister is known for his caring demeanor and personalized approach to dentistry. When you visit our practice, Dr. Pfister will take the time to get to know you as a person, not just as a patient. Come in today and meet Dr. Pfister or one of our other highly qualified dentists, Nicholas Magro, DMD, or Donna Cotrupe, DDS.

Featured Treatments

Dental Crowns

A tooth that has been damaged due to trauma or decay can be restored and protected with a durable dental crown. Following treatment, our dentists can place a crown over the compromised tooth, protecting it from further damage and often preventing the need for extraction. Our crowns are made of advanced dental ceramics that look incredibly natural and blend in with the rest of your smile. At Aesthetic Oral Arts, we use CEREC® technology to create custom crowns in one visit.


Explore Dental Crowns

Cosmetic Dentistry

Even if you have good oral hygiene, you may have dental issues such as stains, discoloration, crooked teeth, or excess gum tissue that detract from the appearance of your smile. Our dentists can work with you to develop a custom cosmetic dentistry plan to address aesthetic issues on your gums or teeth. During a free consultation at our New Hartford, NY, office, our dentists can review your options and show you how cosmetic dentistry can transform your smile.

Explore Cosmetic Dentistry

Dental Implants

Missing teeth can make eating and speaking difficult, hurting your health and social life. When you lose a tooth, the bone tissue in your jaw has nothing to support and begins to deteriorate. Dental implants are the only treatment proven to stop jawbone atrophy. Implants work like tooth roots and provide support for dental restorations such as crowns, bridges, and dentures. Dr. Pfister can perform every step of your implant treatment on-site without sending you to an outside doctor.

Explore Dental Implants

Our Complete Services

“Dr. Pfister Makes Me Feel So at Ease” More Happy Patients


Michele Nelson


Google logo

I love it here. My anxiety at the dentist is pretty bad. Dr. Pfister makes me feel so at ease. He has THE BEST chair side manner. I LOVE Mila as well. I am o o glad I decided to give them a try.

View on Google

Hallie Kowalsky


Google logo

Staff is very friendly, professional and knowledgeable.Dr.Timothy Pfister is a very caring knowledgeable dentist providing you with valuable information so you as a patient can make a well informed decision.

View on Google
“I first was very, very impressed with the advancement of the technology at Dr. Pfister's office. I was really wowed by that. I didn't have to leave this building. All of the work was done here.” Satisfied Patient

Giving Back to Our Community One Smile at a Time

before dental care
after dental care
Dr. Pfister volunteered with the Rescue Mission in Syracuse to transform this patient's smile. Extensive decay, old dental work, and long-term drug use had taken a serious toll on his smile. After having his smile restored by Dr. Pfister, he was able to find a new job and experience a better quality of life.

Interested in Same-Day Treatments?  Contact Our Staff to Learn More 

Same-day crowns, veneers, and implant placements can drastically reduce your treatment time, but some patients may not be the best candidates for same-day dental care. For example, patients may need to fully recover from a bone graft and other treatments before receiving implants. Dr. Timothy Pfister can determine whether same-day treatments fit your needs during your exam and consultation.

Start exploring your treatment options. Contact our dentists or request a consultation by calling our office at:

Dr. Pfister and client looking at teeth

Advanced Technology

Our dentists believe in using the latest tools and equipment available in the field of modern dentistry to provide our community of New Hartford with the best possible care. Combined with the extensive experience of our dentists, you can be confident that you will receive the world-class dental care you deserve during your appointment at our welcoming dental practice. Advanced tools we use include:

  • Digital X-rays
  • i-CAT 3-D Imaging
  • Cone Beam 3-D Computed Tomography
  • DIAGNOdent™ Cavity Detection
  • VELscope® Oral Cancer Screening
  • Intraoral Cameras
  • Tekscan® Pressure Mapping

We also offer various types of sedation to keep you comfortable throughout your appointment.

Discover a Relaxing Experience  With Sedation Dentistry at Our New Hartford Practice 

If you have dental anxiety, we can help keep it in check with various forms of sedation dentistry. We offer three forms of conscious sedation to help you feel more comfortable in the dentist’s chair:

Nitrous Oxide

Commonly known as “laughing gas,” nitrous oxide is our lightest form of sedation to help you relax. Nitrous oxide starts working almost immediately and leaves your system just as quickly so you can drive home after a procedure. At Aesthetic Oral Arts, nitrous oxide is free.  

Oral Sedation

Oral sedation is usually taken as a pill on the day of your dental treatment. The effects of this method take a little longer to activate, so you’ll need to ingest the pill before your appointment. The strength of oral sedation varies, but you will need to schedule a ride home from our office. 

IV Sedation

We work with a trained nurse to deliver the strongest form of conscious sedation through an IV. IV sedation places patients into a dream-like state, and afterward, they remember little to nothing about the procedure. IV sedation also requires you to find a ride home. 

"The Absolute Best Dentist Office I've Ever Been To"


Lori Tucker


Google logo

Wonderful Staff! From the minute I walked in the door I was greeted by staff and felt very comfortable. Extremely Professional and friendly! The absolute best dentist office I've ever been to. If you don't have dental insurance they have Many discounts! I highly recommend this Dental Office!

View on Google

Ruth Staggs


Google logo

They go to the extreme to make sure you are comfortable all the way through each procedure and my experience with Dr. Cotrupe has been extraordinary. She is very thorough and very caring and considerate concerning any anxiety or discomfort. I highly recommend this practice.

View on Google
Dr. Pfister

Aesthetic Oral Arts

The team of friendly dental professionals at Aesthetic Oral Arts is dedicated to providing patients with world-class care using state-of-the-art technology. After listening to your concerns, our dentists can help you achieve an attractive, healthy smile with one of our advanced treatment options. We offer:

  • Free consultations
  • Flexible financing options
  • Same-day dentistry

To schedule an appointment at our dental office serving our community of New Hartford, NY, contact us online or call (315) 724-7121.

Get In Touch Today

Rate, Review & Explore

Social Accounts Sprite
Google map image of our location in 4388 Middle Settlement Rd  New Hartford, NY

New Hartford Office

4388 Middle Settlement Rd
New Hartford, NY 13413

Closed Today

(315) 724-7121 Send a message